CEC Still Weighing Refinery Resupply Rule
CALGARY, CANADA (DTN) — The California Energy Commission (CEC) has yet to decide requirements for fuel resupply lost during planned refinery maintenance, after preliminary analysis found no consistent price pattern around outages.
AB X2-1, passed by lawmakers in 2024 after sharp price spikes, gave the commission authority to set resupply planning rules for planned refinery maintenance. The law assumes planned maintenance contributes to supply shortfalls and higher prices; a premise CEC is still testing.
In four of five cases where a large, planned outage overlapped with a large unexpected one, the gap between California and U.S. retail gasoline prices widened in the run-up to the maintenance shutdown and generally stabilized once it began, William Leung, chief economist in the commission’s Energy Assessments Division, told a workshop this week.
CEC officials cautioned the findings are descriptive, rest on a small sample, cover less than a full maintenance cycle and cannot show whether planned maintenance affects prices.
The regulator is weighing four resupply approaches: a strong requirement that applies at smaller gasoline production losses and requires more fuel replacement, a softer rule for larger losses requiring less resupply, no regulation at all, or other tools such as minimum inventory or a state fuel reserve.
However, strict resupply requirements could lead refiners to delay planned maintenance to improve their replacement position, CEC officials said, and a delay could raise the chance of unplanned outages. California’s Department of Industrial Relations has raised the same concern.
Dan Lashof, a senior fellow with the World Resources Institute, urged the commission to consider 90-day fuel stocks like those International Energy Agency members must hold, with an entity independent of refiners managing them. He added that California could ease imports and competition by dropping its unique gasoline specifications.
CEC must compare how arbitrage responds to unplanned refinery outages in California and in import-reliant regions with in-state refining, such as PADD 1B, said Jeremy Martin, fuels policy director at the Union of Concerned Scientists.
This would allow the commission to test whether differences between regions stem from market structure, vertical integration, California’s unique gasoline specifications or a lack of merchant terminals and storage, which can hinder arbitrage and market entry, he added.
The Western States Petroleum Association opposed new mandates, arguing that imports cannot replace in-state refining and citing port and marine terminal limits and California Air Resources Board at-berth rules that affect tanker calls in Southern California and extend to Northern California in 2027.
Refiners already prepare for maintenance by building inventory, buying replacement product and leasing storage tanks, said Stephen Konig, director of state government affairs for Marathon Petroleum. He added that CEC should count carrying, working capital, storage, terminaling and freight costs when it develops the rules.
CEC will next test whether market participants can profit from price gaps and how fast imports arrive after outages, and it plans to present the results at a workshop in early 2027.
(c) Copyright 2026 DTN, LLC. All rights reserved.