A Country Worth Fighting For
The views expressed are those of the individual author and not necessarily those of DTN, its management or employees.
(DTN photo by Philip Shaw)
It is that time of year when everything is in overdrive in farm country. Harvest time might be getting over for some of our friends in Western Canada, but of course there are still others still at it.
In my part of southwestern Ontario, it’s been a big week with soybeans being harvested with a dry stretch of weather. If there’s one thing Canadian agriculture has in common, it’s the harvest push. There is nothing quite as intense as the actual work of a fall harvest. It’s something we have all in common whether you are from Grand Prairie, Alberta, Saints-Anges, Quebec or Dresden, Ontario.
It is with that as a backdrop that I wanted to talk about something that is a bit uncomfortable this week. As many of you know, I don’t talk about politics very much in this column, even though over a period of almost 40 years there’s been lots of that. However, I thought I should address a couple elephants in the room that are currently percolating in some parts of Canadian farm country. With the election of the Parti Quebecois in Quebec this week, one of them is Quebec separation, something we’ve talked about many times over the last 40 years. The other is a threat of separation from Alberta, which is much newer.
Through the years, there has always been a separation movement in Quebec, but nothing more than fringe in the rest of the country. On top of this it is a very difficult time for Canada now when we are in a trade war with the most powerful country in the world who has always been our best ally. Threats regarding the 51st state, as well as a barrage of disparaging language from American leaders, have shaken the country. Add in the political instability caused by the threat of separation, and it’s something the rest of us just don’t need.
Needless to say, there are different opinions and certainly some of those are in Canadian farm country. If you have read my column over the last almost 40 years, you will know that I often focus on farmers in Quebec. I’ve had the opportunity to speak in Quebec farm country many times, as well as helping lead them in protest. Farmers feel the Quebec nation in their soul, and they have an allegiance to the National Assembly in Quebec City. They are Quebecers first and Canadians second.
Last week Quebecers elected the separatist Parti Quebecois to a minority government with only 28% of the popular vote. This government has promised a referendum on Quebec’s sovereignty during its first term, although its leader wants to delay the vote until President Trump’s term ends.
In Alberta it’s totally different. On Oct.19, Albertans will be asked if Alberta should remain a province of Canada or should its government begin the constitutional legal process required to hold a binding provincial referendum on separation. In other words, separation from Canada is the end game appear for an independent Alberta. The question is, why would they even go there? Aren’t there enough lessons from Quebec to see how divisive referenda can be?
The Alberta farmer I do not know as well, even though I’ve been asked to speak on two occasions in that beautiful province. The first time was in Grand Prairie, and the second time was in Edmonton. I had always heard about western grievance against the federal government, but I never equated any of the separation talk due to culture like you see in Quebec. However, I have been accused of being just an “easterner” by some angry farmers on social media. Thankfully, in the last two referendums on Quebec’s sovereignty in 1980 and 1995, social media wasn’t even a thing.
Unfortunately, these ideas do create lots of uncertainty. It also opens up the possibility of things happening that you could have never expected. For instance, in the 1995 referendum, Canada was almost lost by 30,000 votes. The point being, if you don’t go there, it’s not going to happen. However, if you do, as Premier Daniel Smith has done in Alberta, there is a possibility that it could happen. Ditto for Quebec.
In many ways it’s a long story, and in many ways it’s also familiar. Keep in mind I have several Bangladeshi friends that have lived in one place in the world all their lives, but the country has changed its name three times. Canada can be divided too, but it is so worth fighting for. Nevertheless, threats are coming from the South, and threats are coming internally.
It has resulted in the Canadian dollar going down to the 70-cent level. Of course, it raises the level of uncertainty, something Canadian agriculture doesn’t really need any more of. As we look ahead, the rest of us can only hope our friends in Alberta and Quebec can see their way forward as Canadians. We have enough to worry about in agriculture without adding the possibility of our country breaking apart. When the combines are rolling, and the trucks are hauling grain, nobody asks what province you come from. We are all Canadians trying to make a living in a business that never gets any easier. In my book, that is still worth something, and it is something we should be careful not to take for granted.
Philip Shaw can be reached at philip@philipshaw.ca
Follow him on social platform X @Agridome
(c) Copyright 2026 DTN, LLC. All rights reserved.